Ah HA!
The Issue (date attribute) is not being pulled in and seeing as all the other attributes are the same, they're showing as one.
My problem now is getting the correct date format in my CSV. For some reason, it's not pulling the dates in.
The date format is set to MMMM yyyy in the attribute but I can't match it in my CSV. I've tried setting it to text fields and date fields and it doesn't seem to be working.
I'll keep trying various options.